Monday, July 16, 2012

Back on the Train

***rather big pause, was away from Sampa.  back, trying to get back on the horse***

We are getting a free month of the Estado de São Paulo at home.  We don't know what to do with this traditionally conservative newspaper.  I am googling paper machê projects. Today's metro section, however, featured a number of stories about the São Paulo metro system, one of my pet interests.

The title of the lead article pretty much says a lot about the state of the São Paulo metro system.  "Overfilled trains force Metro to close park and rides." Essentially, the metro had a project to create an integrated ticket that would include twenty-four hour parking and two metro rides (there and back).  They had already rolled out two parking lots, but are going to have to cut the entire program because they can't encourage any more ridership during rush hours.  How ridiculous is that!!  To say that they are over capacity is putting it mildly.  During rush hour, you can wait one or two trains to get on.  And these trains are full to the brim, you're often touching multiple people, and there's no way around it.

The irony about this article is that it shows how far behind demand the metro system is, that it becomes impossible to plan how to one day meet that demand.  Oddly enough, straight-forward solutions create new problems.   A perfect example are transfer stations.  In general, you want transfer stations (with two or more lines).  This offers riders more flexibility, which means more circulation and fewer bottle-necks.  In the past year, a new "yellow" line opened up, and was dubbed: "the transfer line" (a linha de baudiações).  The yellow line would connect to all three existent subway lines, (blue, red, green) is planned to connect one day to the planned orange line (what will be the "line of the universities"), and also connects to one of the regional train lines (emerald).  In theory, the yellow line was (among other things) supposed  to ease the overloading of a section of the blue line that connected the red and green lines.  


But what happened?

Well, a couple things.  The yellow line did reduce traffic on the problematic stretch of the blue line by about 20%.  The blue line is still overcapacity, though.  Two other things have happened, however.  First, because the emerald line has now become much more accessible to the rest of the rest of the metro grid via its new transfer station, the line's ridership has now surpassed capacity.  Second, the Luz station, which was supposed to be a super transfer station between the blue, yellow metro plus the ruby and coral regional lines was completely overwhelmed.  The transit authority stopped Ruby line service to the Luz station in order to try to reduce the number of people going through the station.  This has created other problems, as now those riders need to take more cumbersome journeys via other stops.  And so on.

This is not to say that I am anti-expansion.  Much to the contrary!  Certainly, this overcrowding on the metro helps out other transportation, like car, bike and bus traffic.  And the system must and will expand.  Various lines are growing, two lines are being built, and four more are planned.  As more lines criss-cross one another, the stress on individual lines will subside, and these collateral effects might fade.  Maybe the Luz station might one day service all four lines again.  In the meantime, and by meantime I mean the next twenty years, São Paulo is probably going to face a lot of these unintended problems in their still fragile subway ecosystem.

No comments:

Post a Comment