Before you assume too much from the title of this post, fear not. The impossibility of imponderabilia is not the end but the new beginning of this blog.
In March, I wrote that this blog would record the thoughts and observations I had on everyday life in São Paulo. I imagined that these observations would come from stolen moments, when and where the sheer enormity of life in a new location would foster acts of passive contemplation. I imagined that the mise-en-scenes that I would write here would work both with and against the ethnographic information that I was gathering in my "proper research." In contrast, I imagined this part of the ethnographic experience to be somewhat improper, counter-methodological, and hence somewhat illicit and exciting.
My ambiguous relationship towards imponderabilia is, of course, at the heart the of anthropological and ethnographic traditions. Imponderabilia, as I read Malinowski's advocation for it, is both the content that enfleshes social structure and the filter through which it becomes available. The only way out of imponderabilia was to give oneself over to it. As Malinowski envisioned, you sit around long enough in one place, and the world begins to unfold itself around you. Imponderabilia is thus less a methodology, and more a mobilization of aesthetic and epistemological first principles.*
Mobilizing imponderabilia seems to be more and more difficult in contemporary anthropology, working in post-industrial sites, and using modern methods. Urban anthropology, globalization, multi-sited and scale-jumping research, networks, media circulation, etc. appear to emphasize mobilities that require the anthropologist to chase after the site instead of remaining in it. Repeated in many forms, the new wisdom seems to be, the techniques anthropologists used in the village just won't work any more. To a large extent, I agree, and would add that we would be remiss to treat villiage-ify any of these sites instead of letting the mode of study emerge from the reconfigured site itself.
Nevertheless, I find it necessary to understand why impoderabilia fails in many contemporary ethnographic projects. And I want to take my own experiences as a point of reflection on this.
[More Under the Fold!]
First...the impossibility of impoderabilia. Rembember Malinoswki's command to 'imagine yourself on an island" (or something like that), you have nothing to do, and when you finally have no more books to read and horribly bored, you go talk to the natives. Condescension and racism aside (and a big aside that is, to be sure), the beginning of fieldwork for Malinowski is boredom. You only go and try to figure things out when you have nothing better to do. Boredom in this sense is not the lack of excitement so much as the lack of distraction. As Sigfried Kracauer writes somewhere, this form of boredom is precisely what is unavailable to those living under regimes of modernity, in mass mediated and urban settings. For Kracauer, the constant availability of distraction destroys all opportunity for the critical reflection that arises out of boredom.
When I arrived in São Paulo, I had also arrived a bit socially isolated and bored. Of course, I wasn't resisting talking to the natives so much as I was waiting for them to return my phone calls and emails. Yet I had a lot of time and my hands and a need to justify why I decided to move my life to another continent for a year and a half. So, I began to write down everything that I saw. Reading it now, my early notes are of varying quality and usefulness to the project at hand. But, again, the non-utility was kind of exciting to me. So, what went wrong with this project on everyday life? Well, everyday life. After about a month I started having more and more things to do, meetings to attend, proper research to attend to. I became more integrated into the culture of work and distraction that is part of my research. Sometimes this involved sitting in five hours of meetings and writing up on them for three hours at home. In other words, an eight hour work day with a routine. This routine incorporated me socially into my fieldsite, but it has also instrumentalized my time in a way that has made the mental registration of imponderabilia difficult, if not impossible.
So, what is next for a project on impossible imponderabilia? I will keep you posted. In the meantime, Kracauer's opposition of distraction and reflection reminds me of a comment my professor made about an assignment I did for an ethnographic methods class. For the week on fieldnotes, I tried to observe customer-salesperson interactions in the apple store on Michigan Ave. in Chicago. All I managed to write about was the music blaring overhead and the various videos that made it very hard to pay attention to what people next to me were saying. I thought I had failed to get the information I was looking for, but my professor pointed out something else. Everything that I was recording, everything that made it difficult for me to concentrate, was sesnory stimuli that was also making it hard for customers to concentrate and make informed decisions. Unwittingly, I had captured something else about the consumer experience.
And maybe it is this 'something else' that I am ultimately trying to capture in this blog. Something else is the lesson of ethnography, which is always a testament to the necessity of surprise in the face of the instability of life. Something else that honors the struggle towards imponderabilia, but recognizes how modern life makes it literally unthinkable. Stay tuned....
*Wow, this paragraph ended up really, really Kantian. I am going to have to think about the connections of imponderabilia to the first and third critiques.
No comments:
Post a Comment